Rusty Paul in Mayoral Runoff

After failing to achieve 50% +1, three-term Sandy Springs Mayor Rusty Paul advances to runoff.

Sandy Springs Mayor Rusty Paul is headed to a December 2, 2025 runoff after falling short of the majority needed to win outright in the November 4 municipal election. Paul, who has served as mayor since 2013, captured roughly 43 percent of the vote in a crowded field of challengers. Dontaye Carter, a community advocate and former city spokesperson, finished second with about 21 percent, securing a place in the runoff. The remaining votes were divided among City Council members Andy Bauman and Jody Reichel, who each earned under 20 percent.

Paul’s long tenure has been defined by major redevelopment initiatives, including the City Springs civic center project, extensive infrastructure investments, and efforts to manage rapid growth while preserving neighborhood character. Before becoming mayor, Paul served as a Georgia State Senator, chaired the Georgia Republican Party, and held a senior post in the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development under President George H.W. Bush. Supporters point to his experience and steady leadership, while critics argue that Sandy Springs needs new energy and a stronger focus on housing affordability and inclusion.

With early voting scheduled to begin November 18, both campaigns are expected to intensify outreach efforts. Runoff elections typically draw smaller turnouts, giving ground operations and early-vote mobilization outsized influence. For Paul, the challenge will be consolidating his broad—but incomplete—plurality into a true majority, while Carter will aim to unite anti-incumbent voters seeking a generational and leadership change. The December 2 runoff will ultimately determine whether Sandy Springs continues under Paul’s experienced hand or moves toward a new political direction.